Development record
2026-08-30 — itd-179 delta close: body scope does NOT close consequence A, and the record says so. An unclosed opener in the BODY still masks the body, so an appended entry still cannot read back and every triage route still refuses — verified by a test that stayed red at the body-scope commit and only passed at the next one. What makes that survivable is the other two halves: the refusal names the opener's line and construct instead of the grounds operand, and promote dry-runs the append against the pre-flight bytes so a deterministic refusal mints nothing (iss-2608301803423101). Rejected: refusing every record carrying an unclosed opener, which would refuse writes that succeed — a `## Grounds` section ABOVE the opener takes the entry perfectly well. Rejected: a file-relative line number in the refusal, because the triage verbs append after setting their note field and the number would name a line the unwritten record on disk does not have; the number is body-relative and the opener's text is quoted beside it.
2026-08-30 — itd-179 delta close: body scope does NOT close consequence A, and the record says so. An unclosed opener in the BODY still masks the body, so an appended entry still cannot read back and every triage route still refuses — verified by a test that stayed red at the body-scope commit and only passed at the next one. What makes that survivable is the other two halves: the refusal names the opener's line and construct instead of the grounds operand, and promote dry-runs the append against the pre-flight bytes so a deterministic refusal mints nothing (iss-2608301803423101). Rejected: refusing every record carrying an unclosed opener, which would refuse writes that succeed — a ## Grounds section ABOVE the opener takes the entry perfectly well. Rejected: a file-relative line number in the refusal, because the triage verbs append after setting their note field and the number would name a line the unwritten record on disk does not have; the number is body-relative and the opener's text is quoted beside it.
Frontmatter
| id | dcn-2608300000000020 |
|---|---|
| type | decision |
| date | 2026-08-30 |
.abcd/work/decisions/dcn-2608300000000020-itd-179-delta-close-body-scope-does-not.md
open on GitHub ↗ · commit history ↗
mentions3
- iss-2608301803423101an unclosed comment or fence anywhere in an issue record blinds every grounds triage route permanently and promote orphans a draft per attempt
- iss-2608301908270888an unclosed comment or fence in an issue body still locks the record out of every triage verb and no open record tracks it
- itd-179The reasoning behind what was pursued no longer evaporates at the gate — readiness and triage record grounds for the conjecture, not only the decision