Development record
2026-10-24 — Held for the product thinker: criteria 3 and 5 of itd-2610240823055889 conflict when the assistant's settings file exists. Criterion 3 makes the status line (the assistant's settings) its own person-approved question, and criterion 5 allows four questions (download, shell settings, plan, identity) plus one per tool, so a fresh account can be asked five. The build keeps the status-line question separate, the side on which nothing changes without a yes, and the spec close records criterion 5 as not met in that case until the product thinker rules: count the status line in the budget, fold it into the download question, or move it onto the plan screen.
2026-10-24 — Held for the product thinker: criteria 3 and 5 of itd-2610240823055889 conflict when the assistant's settings file exists. Criterion 3 makes the status line (the assistant's settings) its own person-approved question, and criterion 5 allows four questions (download, shell settings, plan, identity) plus one per tool, so a fresh account can be asked five. The build keeps the status-line question separate, the side on which nothing changes without a yes, and the spec close records criterion 5 as not met in that case until the product thinker rules: count the status line in the budget, fold it into the download question, or move it onto the plan screen.
Frontmatter
| id | dcn-2610241228598485 |
|---|---|
| type | decision |
| date | 2026-10-24 |
.abcd/work/decisions/dcn-2610241228598485-held-for-the-product-thinker-criteria-3.md
open on GitHub ↗ · commit history ↗
mentions3
- iss-2611030744340532The board lists itd-2610240823055889 as next and ready ('implement against the spec body'), though its only open spec, spc-2610242112593216, says in its summary that it holds until the product thinker rules on dcn-2610241228598485; the hold is prose, so neither the board nor abcd build can see it, and a build would run against an unruled spec.
- itd-2610240823055889Setting abcd up is short, plain, and finishes
- spc-2610242112593216setup-question-budget