The comparative dirty gate does not cover the disposition and admission families, so an uncommitted fate silently selects a different candidate run. refuseDirtyIncludedPaths in internal/core/reading/assemble.go names LintConfigPath and PresetConfigPath by hand but not the two ledger families the comparative derivation reads from the filesystem: capture.ItemFate walks the dispositions and admissions directories to decide whether a widening run is still pre-admission. Commit a disposition on a candidate, delete it in the working tree alone, and the assembly admits the run and mints a manifest whose named commit still carries the disposition — a re-run at that commit would derive a different candidate set. Expected: at the comparative position any dirty path under either family is included, so the gate refuses and names it.

The comparative dirty gate does not cover the disposition and admission families, so an uncommitted fate silently selects a different candidate run. refuseDirtyIncludedPaths in internal/core/reading/assemble.go names LintConfigPath and PresetConfigPath by hand but not the two ledger families the comparative derivation reads from the filesystem: capture.ItemFate walks the dispositions and admissions directories to decide whether a widening run is still pre-admission. Commit a disposition on a candidate, delete it in the working tree alone, and the assembly admits the run and mints a manifest whose named commit still carries the disposition — a re-run at that commit would derive a different candidate set. Expected: at the comparative position any dirty path under either family is included, so the gate refuses and names it.

Grounds

• pursued: the comparative assembly refuses whenever the fate records the derivation reads differ between the working tree and the commit the manifest names, so a manifest never promises a re-run that would derive a different candidate set. What would show it wrong: an assembly that succeeds while a dispositions/ or admissions/ path is dirty, or a refusal over a clean tree whose fate records are merely present.