intent plan's comment and surface claim a refusal leaves the record byte-identical with no spec minted, but the spec is minted before the intent write: with planned/ read-only, intent plan refuses (exit 2) and leaves an orphan spc file under specs/open/ that a retry reuses. Self-healing, not atomic; the claim overstates it.

intent plan's comment and surface claim a refusal leaves the record byte-identical with no spec minted, but the spec is minted before the intent write: with planned/ read-only, intent plan refuses (exit 2) and leaves an orphan spc file under specs/open/ that a retry reuses. Self-healing, not atomic; the claim overstates it.

Grounds

• pursued: with planned/ read-only, intent plan on a null-spec planned record refuses and no spec names the intent afterwards, and the retry mints exactly one (TestPlanInPlaceRefusalAfterTheMintLeavesNoSpec); a spc file left under specs/open/ after such a refusal would show it wrong