abcd intent consistency pins its report to HEAD (review_of_commit) but reads the brief and the intents from the working tree, so an uncommitted or untracked edit to a brief page or an intent is quoted in an append-only report under a commit that does not hold the quoted text at the cited path:line, and nothing in the report says so. itd-28's dirty-tree policy for review pins is to tag dirty: true and not block; the consistency emit neither tags nor refuses.

abcd intent consistency pins its report to HEAD (review_of_commit) but reads the brief and the intents from the working tree, so an uncommitted or untracked edit to a brief page or an intent is quoted in an append-only report under a commit that does not hold the quoted text at the cited path:line, and nothing in the report says so. itd-28's dirty-tree policy for review pins is to tag dirty: true and not block; the consistency emit neither tags nor refuses.

Grounds

• pursued: a report written over an uncommitted corpus edit says dirty: true and names the path; shown wrong if a report pins a commit that does not hold a quoted end and carries no dirty mark