itd-28 ac-1 promises review_of_commit written by the tool; no abcd path writes a dated review folder, so the pin is a charter-template obligation on the author whose absence RD004 refuses, and the narrowing was settled by the implementer in Decision 3 rather than by the product thinker

itd-28 ac-1 promises review_of_commit written by the tool; no abcd path writes a dated review folder, so the pin is a charter-template obligation on the author whose absence RD004 refuses, and the narrowing was settled by the implementer in Decision 3 rather than by the product thinker

Remedy grounds (2026-09-29)

Confirmed at this base: no code path writes a review folder (internal/core/reviews/reviews.go only reads the pin). Rejected: a hook that stamps the sha after the fact, which pins whatever HEAD is at stamp time rather than the commit reviewed.