Development record
Four of the product thinker's rulings of 2026-10-14 in iss-2610140652230444 are carried by no record once itd-2610240922461281 takes the review set: the top class consulted (1) for a third read of release-blocking security changes (the shell guard, installing and updating the binary, secrets, what is published), (2) before a design-heavy plan locks, and (3) when the executor fails twice with the same failure fingerprint; and (4) code is written by the middle class. The review-set intent carries only the fourth consult case (the pair disagrees), as its judge. Each of the four sits at a seam outside the review round (a release gate, the planning interview, the fix-round loop, the implementer's route), so each is its own piece of work; deferred out loud here rather than left inside a draft's Decisions where a reader of the issue would not find it.
Four of the product thinker's rulings of 2026-10-14 in iss-2610140652230444 are carried by no record once itd-2610240922461281 takes the review set: the top class consulted (1) for a third read of release-blocking security changes (the shell guard, installing and updating the binary, secrets, what is published), (2) before a design-heavy plan locks, and (3) when the executor fails twice with the same failure fingerprint; and (4) code is written by the middle class. The review-set intent carries only the fourth consult case (the pair disagrees), as its judge. Each of the four sits at a seam outside the review round (a release gate, the planning interview, the fix-round loop, the implementer's route), so each is its own piece of work; deferred out loud here rather than left inside a draft's Decisions where a reader of the issue would not find it.
Frontmatter
| id | iss-2610240946046901 |
|---|---|
| type | issue |
| lifecycle | open |
| severity | minor |
.abcd/work/issues/open/iss-2610240946046901-four-of-the-product-thinker-s-rulings-of.md
open on GitHub ↗ · commit history ↗
mentions3
- iss-2610140652230444Every review should run as a pair of models from two classes, with the top class only an occasional advisor. The classes are vendor-neutral: top, middle, the class below it, and smallest (the scale itd-2610100704270254 uses). For one vendor today, Anthropic, they are Fable, Opus, Sonnet and Haiku. The rule is stated in classes so it survives model churn and holds for any vendor whose models map onto them.
- itd-2610240922461281The review set is a setting, in model classes
- spc-2610240951109420a-person-sets-how-many-models-review