Development record
Whether abcd intent ready gates on the claim_sections start check was ruled on 2026-11-01 (dcn-2611011332291422): it gates. Before that ruling, gating it would have reversed their ruling on iss-2609091009111294, which kept the mechanism and scope-condition rows advisory, so intent ready can report READY on a record that abcd build then refuses at claim_sections, as itd-39 showed on 2026-10-31. Split from iss-2610311501473953 so its drain-buildable half carries no ruling.
issueopenminoriss-2610312234315875
Whether abcd intent ready gates on the claim_sections start check was ruled on 2026-11-01 (dcn-2611011332291422): it gates. Before that ruling, gating it would have reversed their ruling on iss-2609091009111294, which kept the mechanism and scope-condition rows advisory, so intent ready can report READY on a record that abcd build then refuses at claim_sections, as itd-39 showed on 2026-10-31. Split from iss-2610311501473953 so its drain-buildable half carries no ruling.
Frontmatter
| id | iss-2610312234315875 |
|---|---|
| type | issue |
| lifecycle | open |
| severity | minor |
.abcd/work/issues/open/iss-2610312234315875-whether-abcd-intent-ready-gates-on-the.md
open on GitHub ↗ · commit history ↗
mentions4
- dcn-26110113322914222026-11-01 — The product thinker's ruling of 2026-11-01 on iss-2610312234315875: abcd intent ready gates on the claim_sections start check, so READY means abcd build will start. That check binds both claim rows, an unanswered or empty Mechanism and unrecorded Scope Conditions, so this reverses the earlier ruling on iss-2609091009111294 for both rows; the ruling's stated ground, that READY means the build will start, holds only if both gate, so the scope was read from it rather than asked again. A Scope Conditions section holding the token None stated. satisfies its half. Grounds: on 2026-10-31 intent ready called itd-39 READY and the build then refused it at claim_sections. Reverse by a later ruling that makes either row advisory again.
- iss-2609091009111294The ledger's human gates block the ordinary intent flow before the product thinker's language exists: intent ready refuses on scope conditions, mechanism claim and grounds, capture promote and resolve refuse without --grounds, and a lapse capture refuses without --lapsed-at. Each check should report, never refuse, until the rethink of the reading work settles what a human is asked for.
- iss-2610311501473953abcd intent ready itd-39 reported the intent READY on 2026-10-31, listing scope_conditions as an advisory row ('no ## Scope Conditions section — the context claim is unrecorded'), and abcd build itd-39 then refused it at claim_sections for the same missing section. ReadyWithQuestions (internal/core/intent/ready.go) appends only the open-questions start check to the readiness verdict, so READY still does not mean the build will start, the defect iss-2610101610446956 fixed for open questions alone.
- itd-39abcd Surfaces the Right Memory at the Right Moment