Development record
abcd has no read-only convention-audit surface, and the binary gap model is disjoint from the prepare-this-repo skill audit. abcd ahoy --json on a partially-scaffolded repo reports only abcd own install-plumbing gaps (config.json, rules.json, marker blocks, history store) and is silent on the gaps the onboarding skill exists to fix: the missing committed .abcd/work/ tier, the absent AGENTS.md conventions router, and durable decisions leaking into the gitignored layer. The entire Phase 2 gap report had to be produced by hand. Detector: a read-only abcd audit (or extended ahoy doctor) verb that checks the three-tier layout, decision-durability, docs Diataxis/tense, and privacy -- every convention the skill audits by prose. Acceptance corpus (Manuscripts dogfood): (a) missing .abcd/work/ tier undetected, (b) decisions/ vs decisions/adrs/ layout drift undetected, (c) whole convention audit done manually. This is the single highest-value onboarding gap: it is what would make prepare-this-repo engine-backed instead of agent-glue.
abcd has no read-only convention-audit surface, and the binary gap model is disjoint from the prepare-this-repo skill audit. abcd ahoy --json on a partially-scaffolded repo reports only abcd own install-plumbing gaps (config.json, rules.json, marker blocks, history store) and is silent on the gaps the onboarding skill exists to fix: the missing committed .abcd/work/ tier, the absent AGENTS.md conventions router, and durable decisions leaking into the gitignored layer. The entire Phase 2 gap report had to be produced by hand. Detector: a read-only abcd audit (or extended ahoy doctor) verb that checks the three-tier layout, decision-durability, docs Diataxis/tense, and privacy -- every convention the skill audits by prose. Acceptance corpus (Manuscripts dogfood): (a) missing .abcd/work/ tier undetected, (b) decisions/ vs decisions/adrs/ layout drift undetected, (c) whole convention audit done manually. This is the single highest-value onboarding gap: it is what would make prepare-this-repo engine-backed instead of agent-glue.
Frontmatter
| id | iss-86 |
|---|---|
| type | issue |
| lifecycle | resolved |
| severity | major |
.abcd/work/issues/resolved/iss-86-onboarding-audit-not-engine-backed.md
open on GitHub ↗ · commit history ↗
mentions3
- dcn-26071300000000022026-07-13 — `abcd audit` (itd-85): a new read-only repo-conformance verb, distinct from
- itd-85A Read-Only Repo-Conformance Audit
- spc-6issue-capture