an-ideate-verdict-proves-its-own-legs

Summary

Delivers schema version 2 of the ideate verdict, validated by abcd ideate record (internal/core/ideate), and the command page commands/ideate.md updated to it in the same change.

Payload (version 2). schema_version: 2; origin_sources (the sources the idea came from); legs as today, with three changes: a research claim's status takes quoted | verified | falsified | unverifiable; the record-grill leg gains searches (each {terms, places, count}); the adversarial-review leg holds reviewers (each {label, kill_attempts, verdict, sources}) and an optional ruling ({by, verdict, reason}); a top-level reframing string.

Validation, each a refusal with exit 2 that writes nothing:

1. Every record id in every leg resolves (itd-, spc-, iss-, adr- patterns in primary_source, grill record, kill-attempt text and rejected alternatives), through the resolver the grill uses today; the refusal names the leg and the id (criterion 1).
2. primary_source is an https:// address, source:<key> (resolved against the local sources corpus when it exists), or a record id (criterion 2).
3. A record-grill leg with no hits and no searches entry is refused (criterion 3).
4. verdict: reframed without a non-empty reframing is refused (criterion 4).
5. Each reviewer's attempts, verdict and sources are kept under its label (criterion 5); reviewers whose verdicts differ require ruling (criterion 6).
6. A claim with status: verified whose primary_source is in origin_sources is refused; quoted is accepted (criterion 7).
7. schema_version: 1 is refused with a message naming version 2 (criterion 8).

Render. The research note shows the searches table, each reviewer's section, the ruling and the reframing. Verdicts already on record are not parsed.

Command page. Leg 3 tells the runner to give each reviewer one idea per context (criterion 9), and the payload example becomes version 2.

Footprint

• packages: internal/core/ideate, internal/surface/cli, commands
• tests: internal/core/ideate (record_test.go, a new v2_test.go with one case per criterion), internal/surface/cli (the ideate record surface)

Steps

No steps listed: the spec is built as one step. To split it, list the steps in order as 1. <title>, each with - packages: and - tests: indented beneath it; - landed: <pull request or commit> marks a step that has landed.